Providing information to income property owners and managers looking for ways to optimize there earning potential. As well as providing tips and resources for landlords and other real estate investors
Friday, April 27, 2012
When your Tenant Wants a Roommate
by BRENDAN O'BRIEN
Your tenant calls. He’s having some money troubles, and he needs a favor. You think “Oh no.” But this request isn’t what you expected. He wants to… bring in a roommate.
Of course, your tenant had to ask your permission to do this because your lease specified that only those people named in the lease could occupy the unit. (If your lease didn’t specify this, you screwed up, and you don’t have any control over his selection of a roommate. All of your future leases should have this provision.)
How are you going to handle this so that a) you have some control over the new tenant, b) you are financially protected, and c) you don’t have a lot of extra trouble?
You have four options. The first is to simply allow the additional tenant with no written agreement. Obviously, this is a big mistake. The second is to create a new lease that adds the second tenant (so that both sign the same document). I don’t recommend this because there it adds a lot of complications – who is responsible for which damages, are both equally liable for the rent, and so on.
The third is to put the roommate on an entirely separate lease, and create a new one for the original tenant – charging each (almost always) half of the total rent required. Now you have two completely separate tenants in one unit. The danger with that approach is that if one tenant bails, the first one is still a tenant in good standing, yet you’re only getting half the rent you need from your unit.
Here’s a fourth approach that I think is actually the best. Why not have the existing tenant create a separate arrangement with the new roommate? This is not a sub-lease, although it is similar. The new roommate has to follow your rules (as would any guest staying at the apartment). The legal arrangement is essentially an agreement between three parties; the new tenant, the original tenant and yourself. Key points:
The new tenant owes rent and security deposit to the existing tenant, not you
The initial term of the arrangement must end at or before the initial term of your lease arrangement with the original tenant. The arrangement is null and void and the new tenant has no right to the apartment if the original tenant moves out for any reason. The new tenant must follow all the “behavioral” rules established by you in the original arrangement. The new tenant must pass whatever background checks you applied to the first tenant.
There is one legal problem with an arrangement like this. Since the new tenant owes rent to the original tenant, and nothing to you, any agreement between you and this new tenant may not be binding. Generally contracts require consideration to be valid and there is no consideration in your arrangement with the new tenant. Therefore, it makes more sense to create two separate arrangements. The first is between you and the existing tenant, and specifies his obligations in consideration of being able to bring in a roommate. He has to enforce certain rules (the same rules you enforce for him). He can’t sign an agreement with the roommate unless you have approved it (in reality, you will draft it). He can’t bring in a specific roommate without your approval.
Having made such an arrangement with the existing tenant, you can now let him and the new roommate make their own arrangement, previously reviewed by you. The advantage to this system? You get all the rent you are owed without responsibility for a second tenant, and the original tenant gets to keep his place. It’s a win-win.
What if one of the roommates does not meet his obligations?
The new roommate’s obligations are entirely to the original tenant. So if the new guy screws up, it’s up to your original tenant to fix it. He has an obligation to you to do so. For example, suppose the new roommate doesn’t pay the rent owed to the original tenant. It is up to the original tenant to evict him.
It gets more painful if the original tenant doesn’t meet his obligations. Suppose the rent on the apartment is $800. The new roommate faithfully pays his share – say $400 – and the original tenant goes out and blows it all at the track. Now the new tenant is in trouble, because he doesn’t have an arrangement with you, and the original tenant is about to get evicted. That will trigger an eviction of the new roommate according to your arrangement.
That stinks for the roommate, but it’s not your problem. It is up to the original tenant and the roommate to work out.
I’ll be curious to read any comments and suggestions on this idea.
Monday, April 23, 2012
RePost: Outrageous Things Tenants Say as Excuses
Most landlords are quick to say that they have many good, reliable tenants. If not, they’d find another business; tenants are their livelihood. But then there are the rest, that tiny percentage of renters who can’t seem to get it together and aren’t quick to fess up.
And what kinds of things do these tenants say? Below are some favorites from landlords. Tenants take note: If you hear these lines start to come out of your mouth, stop and think a moment. Another strategy — the truth, perhaps — might prove more effective.
It’s not a dog; it’s a barking cat.’
Hmmm … are you sure you want to make that your final answer?
This was Barry Maher several years ago in Santa Barbara, Calif., where he owned a small apartment building. Dogs were not allowed, as outlined in the rental agreement. Cats were.
However, shortly after a young woman moved in, her neighbors complained about barking in the apartment. Maher called the tenant.
“She said, ‘Oh I would never have a dog. But what I have is a special breed. It’s a very rare thing; it’s a dog cat ... a mix of a cat and a dog.’
“It was so blatant and so crazy that I actually spent a moment thinking, ‘Is there really such a thing as a dog cat?’ ” Maher recalled. “And I’m really not an idiot.”
‘But you said I could paint it.’
Did you not know that it’s usually just walls that get painted? And in a color that’s possible to paint over? The entire apartment was purple. The ceiling, the walls, the whole entire apartment was painted lavender,
‘My grandmother died ... again.’
That’s strange: According to our files, your grandmother has died six times recently. At least according to the reasons you’ve provided each time you couldn’t pay the rent.
The sudden need to pay for a funeral is a common claim for a tenants inability to pay.
‘I have to move out. I’m allergic to pet dander.’
How is it, then, that you work as a groomer in a veterinary clinic?
The problem is that once people sign a 12-month lease, there are very few ways to break it. So tenants must come up with their own — at times creative — reasons about why they must leave.
‘The check may have bounced, but at least I paid.’
Actually, mailing a check that isn’t backed by real money isn’t quite the same thing as paying the bill. In fact, it’s not the same thing at all.
‘I was the victim of identity theft.’
OK, that would seem valid, given your bad credit. Except for this catch: Your credit was just as bad before the date your identity was allegedly stolen.
This is a reason frequently given by prospective tenants to explain their poor credit, as well as by existing tenants unable to pay the rent.
‘You can’t come in. There’s too much cash in my bedroom.’
Um, could you put it somewhere safe before we arrive for the inspection?
This tenant apparently didn’t want to an annual walk-through. But this isn’t the best way to keep visitors out. Perhaps the tenant put valuables out of view and entered as scheduled.
‘Someone threw a brick through my window.’
But something’s missing — namely, the glass. Oh, look, it’s on the outside.
“Unless the laws of physics don’t apply here, the window was broken from the inside out, not the outside in,”
‘The ceiling is dripping and we don’t know why!’
Well, do you think the drip might have something to do with the fact that you turned the roof into a swimming pool?
The tenant left clear evidence that it was they who had caused the very leak about which they were complaining. The roof was intentionally flooded and the tenants’ names spray-painted on the tiling next to the words, “Welcome to Silver Beach.”
The roof had a silver-oxide coating and a thigh-high shoulder wall along all the edges. The culprits had plugged the drain with a candle and flooded the entire roof, about the size of a standard swimming pool.
‘The electricity is out and I don’t know why!’
So you say that the power flipped off right after you turned on the microwave, the hair dryer and the toaster at the same time? Do you know anything about circuit loads?
‘See, the walls are almost the same color.’
Gee, I’m sorry that you ran out of paint, but I’m going to have to finish each wall before re-renting the apartment.
My dog ate it
Really?!
Always keep in mind you need to have a sense of humor when dealing with tenant. Especially if you’re going to have more than a couple rental units. You can’t take this stuff personally.”
Sunday, April 22, 2012
Funny but True, Messages Tenants Leave.
The toilet is blocked and we cannot bathe the children until it is cleared.
This is to let you know that there is a smell coming from the man next door.
The toilet seat is cracked: where do I stand?
I am writing on behalf of my sink, which is running away from the wall.
I request your permission to remove my drawers in the kitchen.
Our lavatory seat is broken in half and is now in three pieces.
Will you please send someone to mend our cracked sidewalk? Yesterday my wife tripped on it and is now pregnant.
Our kitchen floor is very damp, we have two children and would like a third, so will you please send someone to do something about it.
Would you please send a man to repair my downspout? I am an old-age pensioner and need it straight away.
Could you please send someone to fix our bath tap? My wife got her toe stuck in it and it is very uncomfortable for us.
When the workmen were here, they put their tools in my wife's new drawers and made a mess. Please send men with clean tools to finish the job and keep my wife happy.
Friday, April 20, 2012
How to Prorate Rent
Many newcomers to property management as well as many tenants do not understand how to prorate a rent payment.
This comes up when a new tenant moves in mid month. Most property managers want all rents due on the first of each month, so the question becomes, how do we figure out what amount of rent is due to accomplish that.
On move in, most income property owners have each new tenant pay a full months rent and the entire security deposit. If the rent is $1200.00 and the deposit is $1200.00 then the tenant must pay $2400.00 to get the keys. If the tenant moves in on the first day of the month, there is no figuring to do. Each month thereafter the tenant will pay $1200.00.
But if the tenant moves in on the 20th of the month, the question is, what does the tenant owe on upon moving in? It is quite easy to figure out as long as you stick to the formula and thought process.
Figure it this way: Every month is considered a 30 Day month, which is what we call a bankers month. If the tenant moves in on the 20th, they were not in the property for 19 days. 30-19 = 11 Days they were in the property. Now take the rent rate $1200 and divide it by 30 days (one month) = $40.00 per day. $40 x 11 days the tenant had possession = $440.00. That is what they owe prior to moving in thereafter the tenant would pay the original amount of 1,200 on the first of every month
.
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
FREE rental application available
I received several inquires from landlords about updating there rental application.
As a Members of the Greater Salem Landlord Association (GSLA) you have free access to a rental application as well as many other forms. Just log onto the members only page of www.salemlandlords.org . If your not a member of the GSLA, you can still obtain these forms for a small fee by logging onto the resource page of www.salemlandlords.org
As a Members of the Greater Salem Landlord Association (GSLA) you have free access to a rental application as well as many other forms. Just log onto the members only page of www.salemlandlords.org . If your not a member of the GSLA, you can still obtain these forms for a small fee by logging onto the resource page of www.salemlandlords.org
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
How to Reject A Rental Application
To protect yourself from potential discrimination complaints filed by applicants you've turned down you need make sure you base your decision based on the information you've collected from your rental application. Please refer to "Does Your Rental Application Ask Enough in a post this past February.
Additionally, you can protect yourself further if you have a standard set of guidelines for evaluating that you apply to every applicant. Decide ahead of time what criteria are most important to you. Give this set of criteria a numerical order. What will you look at first — what reasonable standard do you require? For those who passed the first test, what will come second? Third?
If you check each application and credit history according to that pre-established order as you weed out candidates, you're all set. And you won't have to worry about whether you made a sound decision or have broken any fair housing rules. The following criteria are all valid reasons to turn down an applicant when used as part of a standard set of guidelines.
Poor Credit Record or Insufficient Income: If your applicant's credit history indicates frequent nonpayment of rent or if, based on information submitted, the rent is too high for the reported income, you can turn down an applicant.
Poor Prior-Landlord References: If previous landlords say the applicant's rent payment often came in late or that the apartment was left in poor shape, you can refuse to rent to that person.
Evictions and Civil Lawsuits: If an eviction is noted on the credit report and the landlord won the lawsuit, you can turn that person away. (If, however, the tenant prevailed, you should make your decision using other criteria.) If you have any doubt about whether your decision would be considered valid, consult a lawyer before notifying the applicant.
Criminal Records: You can refuse to rent to anyone who has been convicted of a criminal offense (with the exception of a drug-use conviction). In some locations you may find convictions listed on an applicant's credit report. (An applicant with a prior drug-use conviction is protected by the Fair Housing Amendments Act because the use of drugs is considered a disability. You cannot reject an applicant for previously using drugs, but you can legally refuse to rent to anyone who has been convicted of manufacturing or selling drugs.)
Incomplete or Inaccurate Rental Application: You can reject anyone who has not answered all the questions on your rental application. Likewise if you discover that someone gave you false or inaccurate information, you can reject that person, too.
Unable to Meet Terms of Lease: You don't have to consider anyone who is unable to pay the required security deposit or to rent the apartment for the length of the lease. If you have a one-year lease and they only want the apartment for nine months, it's legal to say “No.”
Pets or Smokers: You can refuse to rent to smokers or people with pets if your space for rent is designated “nonsmoking” or “no pets.” However, if an animal is trained to assist someone who is blind, deaf, or mentally or physically disabled, it must be allowed.
If a couple, married or not, wants to rent an apartment, you must use both of their incomes in determining whether they can afford your rent. If you don't, you risk a discrimination complaint about marital status or sex.
Always Write Down Why
When you reject an applicant, note the reasons for your decision. Put them on the back of the rental application. Then file it and other appropriate documentation. Don't throw any of this information away. You may need it later if a discrimination complaint is filed. The application also might come in handy later if that person tries to rent another apartment from you.
Sunday, April 15, 2012
TO RENT or To NOT, a tenant with a past eviction?
Most Landlords will give a resounding "NO". There is no way you should ever rent to a tenant who has been evicted. And those landlords have a legitimate case and point.However, if you rent to low-income or marginal tenants, you may run into applicants who have been evicted. It’s just a fact of life. Low-income and marginal tenants have a higher incidence of evictions than do renters who earn $100,000 a year.
There can be numerous reasons for those evictions, some that will absolutely disqualify them from renting from you, and some that just mean they had some hard luck and probably will not be evicted again. In a slow rental market (one where it’s hard to find tenants), you might want to consider renting to applicants who have been evicted. If you make it clear that an eviction will not absolutely disqualify them from renting from you, you may find out that they were in a situation that simply made it impossible to pay the rent or that they had a roommate or spouse who created the problem that precipitated the eviction.
Ask on the screening form or rental application for the reason for a past eviction and you may get an explanation that will satisfy you that you will not have to evict them. Of course, you will verify the information they give you.
Be extremely careful, though. You need to satisfy yourself that the applicant is telling you the truth without embellishment and without forgetting to tell you part of the story. Sometimes people really do learn lessons. Other times they haven’t changed a bit, but have gotten really good at telling sob stories to make a landlord’s heart bleed.What follows are some possibly legitimate reasons why a tenant would not have been able to pay his or her rent and was evicted. You decide how much credence to give them. Bad tenants always have an excuse, it is our job to decide if the excuse is legitimate.
Loss of job, layoff
Rent increases Loss of housing subsidy (look at this one carefully, people don’t lose them for no reason)
Loss of other income subsidy, such as child support
Medical, transportation or other crisis
High winter utility bills (then they would have to satisfy you that that would not be a problem now)
Money stolen
Budgeting difficulties (how have they improved now?)
Loss of social service support
Substance addiction
Domestic violence (has the situation that caused it changed?)
Loss of roommate
Poor communication with landlord, case manager, etc.
Here are some reasons for eviction that would make you never, ever want to rent to an applicant:
Damage to unit
Violent crimes
Drug dealing
Prostitution
Child molestation
Domestic violence
Disturbance of neighbors
Drug addicts not in a rehab program
Keeping a filthy unit
Gang members
Left children unsupervised
A rule of thumb is that you want a satisfactory landlord reference between their eviction and their renting from you to show with actual, concrete evidence, rather than just their word for it, that they just may know how to and be ready to be good tenants.
There can be numerous reasons for those evictions, some that will absolutely disqualify them from renting from you, and some that just mean they had some hard luck and probably will not be evicted again. In a slow rental market (one where it’s hard to find tenants), you might want to consider renting to applicants who have been evicted. If you make it clear that an eviction will not absolutely disqualify them from renting from you, you may find out that they were in a situation that simply made it impossible to pay the rent or that they had a roommate or spouse who created the problem that precipitated the eviction.
Ask on the screening form or rental application for the reason for a past eviction and you may get an explanation that will satisfy you that you will not have to evict them. Of course, you will verify the information they give you.
Be extremely careful, though. You need to satisfy yourself that the applicant is telling you the truth without embellishment and without forgetting to tell you part of the story. Sometimes people really do learn lessons. Other times they haven’t changed a bit, but have gotten really good at telling sob stories to make a landlord’s heart bleed.What follows are some possibly legitimate reasons why a tenant would not have been able to pay his or her rent and was evicted. You decide how much credence to give them. Bad tenants always have an excuse, it is our job to decide if the excuse is legitimate.
Loss of job, layoff
Rent increases Loss of housing subsidy (look at this one carefully, people don’t lose them for no reason)
Loss of other income subsidy, such as child support
Medical, transportation or other crisis
High winter utility bills (then they would have to satisfy you that that would not be a problem now)
Money stolen
Budgeting difficulties (how have they improved now?)
Loss of social service support
Substance addiction
Domestic violence (has the situation that caused it changed?)
Loss of roommate
Poor communication with landlord, case manager, etc.
Here are some reasons for eviction that would make you never, ever want to rent to an applicant:
Damage to unit
Violent crimes
Drug dealing
Prostitution
Child molestation
Domestic violence
Disturbance of neighbors
Drug addicts not in a rehab program
Keeping a filthy unit
Gang members
Left children unsupervised
A rule of thumb is that you want a satisfactory landlord reference between their eviction and their renting from you to show with actual, concrete evidence, rather than just their word for it, that they just may know how to and be ready to be good tenants.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






